The list was from a wine magazine, right? The strong presence of pumpkin ales and few other beers from afar isn't too far-fetched for an American wine magazine to be honest considering "availability, [b:1bzp2jqp]buzz[/b:1bzp2jqp], and balance." Lists sound more like a wine thing than a beer thing to me personally. But to be fair, we do make alot of lists and rankings as Americans for some reason.
Hop onto the forums at [url:1bzp2jqp]http://www.beeradvocate.com[/url:1bzp2jqp] if you want discussions and rows about lists and 'best-ofs'-I'd prefer to spend my time trying, brewing, and drinking beer instead.