Mixed reviews for my mild on Saturday! Reuben, Andrew and Richard all had a taste and it was also in the competition. It scored a 34, which I think is a fair reflection on it. The general feedback from the judges was that it was fine but quite one dimensional and needed more speciality malts. My Whitbread yeast was 5 months old when it arrived and there was no life in it after 36 hours so I pitched some dry notty as it was the only other I had. I think this caused it to attenuate a bit more so the beer was a bit drier than I'd have liked. I'd like to rebrew, maybe use a bit more crystal and brown malts and get some fresher yeast but...
My overall thinking though is that even if we produce a decent mild it won't be a showstopper. I happily sup away at pints of cask mild in Wetherspoons but it's rare I find one that's particularly noteworthy. I can't imagine people will be rushing to look up Beoir after having a pint of mild.
A suggestion that did come up though was to stick with mild but jazz it up in someway e.g. with a fruit addition or more bitterness. Raison and peach mild anyone? I can think of a guy in Wexford who would probably be up for brewing that anyway. <!-- s:wink: --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/icon_wink.gif" alt="

" title="Wink" /><!-- s:wink: -->